What Happened the Night of May 17th?

Valparaiso Police confirmed the arrest of 19-year-old Hunter James Lovin of Valparaiso for felony sexual assault. 

Lovin, of Valparaiso, was taken into custody on June 10th. 

According to the police affidavit, the alleged crime took place on May 17th after a party to celebrate the promotion of one of Lovin’s friends. Lovin and the alleged victim knew each other prior to the party that night – according to the police report. 

The victim, a 19-year-old female, said Lovin provided alcohol to the party. She told investigators she had “at least five beers” and “two large swigs” of Fireball whisky – according to the police document. 

According to the arrest report – the next thing the defendant remembers – she woke up in Lovin’s bed. 

Several days later, Lovin and the alleged victim met in the Bass Pro Shop store parking lot in Destin, Florida to talk about what had happened. The alleged victim took two friends with her to the conversation. While in the parking lot – the alleged victim told Lovin she was setting a clear boundary that they should only be friends. She then told Lovin that she had reported the incident to the police. The police report says, “The victim stated that her parents and close friends ‘pushed’ her to report the incident and that she believes taking action about situations like this could potentially save another girl from going through this.”


Hunter James Lovin, 19, is accused by the Valparaiso Police Department of sexual assault stemming from a part that took place in May, 2022

Witness Statements

Valparaiso Police referenced two separate witness statements in the arrest affidavit: one from Lovin’s cousin and another from the co-worker whose promotion the group was celebrating. 

According to both witnesses, the victim was too drunk to consent at the time of the alleged incident. “Witness 1 stated that he observed the victim stumbling a lot to the point where the defendant was helping her walk because she had fallen onto the cooler on the back porch while getting out of the pool.”

Several days after the incident, Lovin allegedly told his cousin – known in the sworn statement as “Witness 2” that he had sex with the victim. Lovin then allegedly told the witness he would no longer hang out with the victim “because of how awkward it was.” Lovin then told his cousin (Witness 2)that he should not tell anyone else about the incident. 

Hunter Lovin Arrest Affadavit

Hunter James Lovin Arrested

After hearing from the two witnesses and the victim, the investigator on the case – Craig Toney interviewed Lovin at the Valparaiso Police Department on June 6th. 

He asked the defendant to explain what happened. 

According to Lovin’s statement – the incident was a consensual one. He told investigator Toney that he had asked for consent “approximately 100 times”. 

At that point – Investigator Toney asked Lovin how the night started. Lovin then asked for his attorney. 

Four days later – Lovin was arrested in relation to the case. 

Next Steps in the Case

The Okaloosa County Jail released Lovin on a $10,000 bond. Lovin’s first court date to answer the charges is July 14th. The court date is at 330PM in the Fort Walton Beach Courthouse Annex Building on Lewis Turner Boulevard


Sexual Assault Resources

If you or someone you care about has experienced sexual assault – there are many local and national resources to use in order to get help. 

National Resources

The National Sexual Assault Hotline is 1.800.656.4673

You can also go to their website – rainn.org

Niceville Sexual Assault Resources

Download our app to stay in the know about niceville

Support local news. get cool stuff.

We’ve never needed local news more than we have today. With newspapers going out of business and fewer reporters around to watchdog local government, cover events or sports, and make sure you know what’s going on in your community


Donate today to keep local, independent and accountable journalism in your community today


Plus, we’ll give you some cool swag when you make your donation monthly

Keep Up With Niceville News

Stop scrolling social media to find out what’s going on in Niceville. Sign up for our weekly newsletter for the info impacting your daily life!

Boat on a Bayou