Last month, right after the hurricane, I wrote what I hoped was a helpful message about
who’s liable when your healthy tree comes down and causes damage to your neighbor. The
answer was – and still is – that event is treated in law as an Act of God. Neither owner is legally
accountable to the other.
But what about the tree? Who owns the tree and who removes it from laying across your
driveway? That tree was “real property”, when standing. Laying on the ground it is personal
property. I have never seen a case, but with any other personal property, if the landowner finds
your stuff (including your tree) on his yard, certainly he has a right to remove it, but my guess is
it still belongs to you subject to his right to remove it. But the bigger question is, if God put it
there, who has a duty to remove it? The answer is, we really don’t know. Like many legal
questions, the secondary answer is that it’s really not worth the cost to find out from a judge. The
far better answer is to get together with your neighbor, make a friend, and share the job of getting
the tree gone. And both of you develop a short memory if you don’t like the outcome. I’ve seen
no case that defines the duty to remove the tree.
Now the question asked, but not answered until last week, by an appellate court in
Florida; What about a diseased or obviously compromised tree? The rotten tree that takes out the
neighbor’s house? We now have an answer: the owner of the tree is responsible. The tree in
Vaughan v. USMI Properties Five, LLC, was obviously rotten and about to fall. The evidence
confirmed that the tree owner knew that, and so did everyone else. No one knew exactly where it
would fall or when, but falling was predictable.
When that tree is in your yard, your insurance company is correct to tell you to take it out.
The damage it does will be your responsibility. Vaughan v. USMI Properties Five, LLC, No.
6D2025-2288, 2026 WL 1234567 (Fla. 6th DCA, Nov. 6, 2026) If you own the property where
the tree will fall the very best time to make a constructive relationship with your neighbor is
before the tree falls. But the decision to remove the tree is his, not yours. But get together if you
can and take it down. Then share a glass of whatever you like and help him plant a new one.
Maybe in a better place.